NRI Chicago doctor
mobilise better health system
Chicao, May 09, 2006
Indian American doctor pushes for healthcare reforms
An Indian American physician, who is president-elect of the Chicago
Medical Society, has said that doctors should take the lead and
work with lawmakers in the US on healthcare reforms that should
include a reduction in fines to be paid in cases of medical negligence.
Shastri Swaminathan, a psychiatrist who has served as president
of the Illinois Psychiatric Society, will take over as Chicago Medical
Society president June 3.
Foremost on his agenda, he said, would be to mobilise physicians
to work towards a better health system that would include reducing
medical malpractice premiums that have to be paid by doctors in
cases of negligence.
"Something must be done before physicians start leaving Illinois.
For the specialties most affected - neurosurgery and obstetrics
and gynaecology - the malpractice premiums have gone sky high,"
Swaminathan told IANS.
"Moreover, medicare reimbursements are a concern. So, as a
physician, you are hit with a triple whammy - the overheads are
going up, malpractice insurance is going up, while the reimbursements
are going down," he said.
Swaminathan said physicians had been "left off the table"
in the current struggle for healthcare reforms.
"The key to working towards healthcare reform is for physicians
to work with the legislators. Today physicians (in the US) are isolated.
There is a need for them to be politically involved and be better
connected to legislators," he said.
"I think physicians have been left off the table (in the debate
on healthcare reforms). But if we physicians don't look after the
patients' interests, who will? It is we who have to shepherd the
According to him, there was also the need for better patient safety
and better interaction with consumer groups.
"We cannot push for medical reforms without working for better
patient safety. And patient safety involves working to eliminate
judgment errors and system errors. Then, doctors, private hospitals
and consumer activists have to come together to present a persuasive
argument for liability reform," he said.
"Physicians have not done an adequate job of building bridges
with consumer groups. We need to do a better job of addressing the
problems of the uninsured, and patients with pre-existing conditions.
As a physician, I cannot refuse to take a patient just because he
or she has had a history of diabetes and is, therefore, high risk."
Swaminathan has been a practising psychiatrist for three decades
and said there had been a change in the attitude of Indians towards
"When I was doing my residency in 1974, I would see one patient
a year. Today I see over 50 annually. The perceptions have changed.
Indians have begun to see mental illness as a bona fide physical
Indian patients with mental illness were benefited because they
had a very strong family network to fall back upon, Swaminathan
said, adding that like other immigrants, Indians, too, were more
comfortable seeing physicians of their own culture.
When he is not seeing patients or involved with healthcare issues,
Swaminathan likes to take centrestage along with his musical group
that performs Hindi pop songs.
Despite being a sought after singer at private events here, Swaminathan
is modest about his talent. "My wife is a much better singer.
I just accompany her on stage," he said.
State lets Medicaid payments
Critics question how state will afford new All Kids plan
By Judith Graham and Christi Parsons
Tribune staff reporters
Published April 14, 2006
Illinois is nearly $1.5 billion behind on payments to doctors, pharmacies,
hospitals and other medical providers, causing experts to wonder
how the state can launch a major new insurance program for children
when it can't even pay current bills.
In recent weeks, doctors have begun complaining loudly about Medicaid
payments that are past due, in many cases, by as many as four months.
As a result, some physicians are limiting the number of poor patients
They and other medical providers argue that Illinois is balancing
its budget on their backs, using unpaid bills as short-term loans
to help keep the state financially afloat.
"If you're not paying your bills, it's easy to make it look
like your books are balanced," said Todd Evers, who owns four
Illinois pharmacies and is waiting for more than $500,000 in Medicaid
Those most affected are physicians, pharmacists and other providers
whose Medicaid patients make up less than 50 percent of their practices.
Medical groups whose practices consist primarily of Medicaid patients
get bills paid much faster.
This two-tier payment system creates a disincentive for many private
medical practitioners to participate in Medicaid and aggravates
long-standing problems with access to care, medical experts said.
Delayed Medicaid payments and budget gamesmanship are nothing new
in Illinois. For years, governors and legislative leaders have approved
budgets knowing the state would run out of money toward the end
of its fiscal year, and simply planned to pay Medicaid bills when
the new fiscal year began in July.
But over the last nine years, the year-end "accounts payable"
tab for Medicaid has grown steadily--it's about triple what it was
in 1997. And although the state borrowed money to clear out backlogged
bills in 2003 and 2005, at the end of this budget year the state
expects to owe $1.7 billion in delinquent Medicaid payments.
That's a big chunk of the more than $7 billion that Illinois spends
on Medicaid each year.
State budget officials say the late payments are largely a byproduct
of the rising costs of health care, as well as partisan bickering
over a Democratic plan to help pay down Medicaid bills. Instead
of cutting benefits or reducing doctors' fees, officials say, the
state is dealing with escalating Medicaid expenses, in part, by
waiting longer before reimbursing providers.
"The governor said, `We're not going to cut eligibility or
rates. What else can we do?'" said Becky Carroll, a spokeswoman
for Gov. Rod Blagojevich's budget office. "So we contain costs,
and we stretch the payment cycle. It's the most painless way to
make sure people get what they need."
Administration officials also say expanding medical coverage under
Blagojevich's All Kids program will put money in the pockets of
more providers. All Kids will offer health insurance to about 250,000
uninsured children in Illinois, beginning in July. State officials
promise to pay for the expansion with savings to come from more
tightly managed care for Medicaid.
But skepticism is high.
"When this goes into effect, the delays
will get even worse," predicted Dr. Shastri Swaminathan,
a Chicago psychiatrist and president-elect of the Chicago Medical
That's because the state's medical expenses
will rise and because physicians who participate in All Kids have
been promised expedited payments. If the funding sources for All
Kids don't cover its full costs, that may strain the Medicaid budget
and slow payments to other providers.
Already, physicians say Medicaid's financial practices make it
extremely difficult for them to pay their staff and suppliers.
Dr. Matthew Johnson of Park Forest said he can't afford to care
for more poor people because he hasn't been reimbursed for treating
patients as long ago as December. When new Medicaid patients call,
Johnson said, "we're turning them away and telling them, sorry,
but the practice is closed." About 20 percent of his patients
are on Medicaid, down from 25 percent a few months ago, he said.
In November, the state took out a $1 billion short-term loan to
help pay down outstanding Medicaid bills, but the situation has
quickly deteriorated again.
The impact of delayed payments isn't evenly distributed.
For instance, pediatricians haven't noticed a significant slow-down
in payments, said Dr. Ed Pont, president-elect of the Illinois chapter
of the American Academy of Pediatrics. Overall, he said, pediatricians
are pleased by a substantial boost in Medicaid payment rates that
took effect Jan. 1 after a legal settlement.
But other doctors say problems are acute.
Swaminathan belongs to a six-doctor practice
where 40 percent of the patients are on Medicaid and payments from
the state are more than 100 days past due.
Since the beginning of the year, he said,
"it's really reached a crisis level for many doctors,"
many of whom he said are taking out loans to get by.
Some Medicaid experts say the payment cycle is almost as bad as
in the early 1990s, when providers typically waited well past 100
days for their money. The problem is fueled partly by growth in
the Medicaid budget, which has swelled by an average of 8 percent
annually since 2000 and will reach $7.8 billion in state spending
next fiscal year. Still, the state's payment gimmicks wouldn't be
necessary if lawmakers budgeted more money to cover escalating costs,
Administration officials claim they could pay providers sooner
if state Treasurer Judy Baar Topinka weren't holding back money
from some of the state's special funds. Topinka--the Republican
challenging Blagojevich for governor this year--believes the legislature
didn't properly approve the transfers.
In any case, the administration said, the state is a reliable source
of payment for doctors and other providers, even if the payments
are often late.
Dr. Samantha Sattler, a family doctor at Logan Primary Care in
Downstate Herrin, isn't waiting to see what the next budget year
Largely because of problems with Medicaid payments, Sattler said
she didn't get a salary for the first three months of this year.
Come July, the 35-year-old doctor is leaving Illinois and moving
to St. Charles, Mo., because, she said, "I can't practice like
this any longer."
She said nearly half of the clinic's patients are enrolled in Medicaid,
and that it's common for the state to kick back invoices saying
there are errors.
This year, she said, the state mistakenly specified that the clinic
should get Medicaid payments in 555 days instead of 45 days. While
the clinic's staff tried to figure out what was wrong, she said,
no Medicaid money arrived. Eventually, the state realized its error
and sent a check for $283,000, a part of what the clinic was owed,
A spokeswoman from the Department of Healthcare and Family Services
said once the error was "discovered, it was fixed immediately."
It wasn't fast enough for Sattler. "Enough is enough,"